Recent reports by Public Eye and Greenpeace’s Unearthed have sought to link Syngenta products to cases of pesticide poisoning recorded in Brazil. We take those allegations seriously. However, our review of the underlying data has identified significant problems with the way the organisations have interpreted and presented it. 

Most importantly, almost half of the cases they attribute to Syngenta as poisonings are not classified in the underlying dataset as confirmed intoxications. Public Eye is aware of this distinction but has chosen not to use the dataset's final classification in its analysis. 

We have also identified cases where ambiguous or misspelled free-text product descriptions have subsequently been interpreted and assigned to particular products and manufacturers by Public Eye and Unearthed. At least one of these produces a demonstrably questionable attribution to Syngenta. 

These are not simply technical distinctions. They materially affect what conclusions can reasonably be drawn from the data. 

Our purpose here is therefore straightforward: to explain what the underlying data says, where our analysis differs from that of Public Eye and Unearthed, and to give readers enough information to draw their own conclusions. 

At the same time, our focus remains firmly on prevention. In 2025 alone, Syngenta trained 95,000 people in Brazil in the safe and responsible use of crop-protection products. 

 

Pesticide poisoning: 
the evidence deserves to be represented accurately 

  1. Almost half of the cases attributed to Syngenta are not classified as confirmed intoxications 

    Public Eye and Unearthed describe these cases collectively as pesticide poisonings. However, almost half of the cases they attribute to Syngenta are not classified in the underlying data as confirmed intoxications. Public Eye has acknowledged this distinction but decided not to use the dataset's final classification in its analysis. 

    This matters because a notification or investigation of a suspected exposure is not necessarily the same thing as a confirmed case of poisoning. 

     

  2. Public Eye and Unearthed created their own product and company classifications 

    The identification of individual products and manufacturers used in their analysis is not, in every case, a classification made by Brazil's Ministry of Health. Public Eye and Unearthed subsequently interpreted and normalised free-text entries in the underlying records, including misspelled, incomplete and ambiguous product names. 

    That introduces an additional layer of interpretation between the original health record and the claims ultimately made about individual companies. 

     

  3.  We found a clear example of a questionable attribution 

    One original SINAN record identifies the product as “PRO GIBB 400”. Public Eye/Unearthed's analysis converted this into Syngenta's Proclaim and consequently attributed the notification to Syngenta. 

    But publicly available manufacturer information identifies ProGibb 400 as a gibberellic-acid product associated with another manufacturer. On the information available, this therefore appears not to be a spelling correction but a different product from a different manufacturer. 

    This example demonstrates why interpreting free-text records requires considerable care and why company-level conclusions should not simply be treated as classifications contained in the original Brazilian health data. 

     

  4. Some cases concern a product Syngenta stopped selling in Brazil years ago 

    Several cases attributed to Syngenta concern Gramoxone. Syngenta stopped selling Gramoxone in Brazil in 2020. 

    The existence of later notifications involving the product therefore does not, by itself, establish when the product was purchased, its provenance, or who supplied it. 

     

We welcome scrutiny and debate about the role of crop protection in agriculture. But serious questions deserve rigorous analysis. Campaigning organisations, companies and the media alike have a responsibility to distinguish clearly between what the underlying evidence establishes and what has subsequently been inferred from it. 

In this case, we believe important distinctions in the Brazilian data have been lost, uncertain product identifications have been presented with greater confidence than the underlying records justify, and cases that the official dataset does not classify as confirmed intoxications have nonetheless been presented as pesticide poisonings. 

That does not diminish the importance of genuine poisoning cases. It is precisely because those cases matter that the evidence deserves to be represented accurately. 

 

Prevention matters: What Syngenta is doing 

Our responsibility is not simply to comply with regulation. It is to do everything reasonably possible to help people use our products safely and responsibly. 

In Brazil, crop protection products are subject to a strict regulatory framework covering their approval and use. Beyond those requirements, Syngenta invests extensively in stewardship, education and practical safety training. 

In 2025 alone, Syngenta trained around 95,000 people in Brazil in the safe use of our products. We were also the first multinational company in the sector to offer free online training through MAPA's Programa Aplicador Legal, helping make practical safety training available to as many people as possible. Our Aplica Certo platform provides additional guidance on responsible product use, dosage, application timing, environmental considerations and personal protective equipment. 

The circumstances behind individual cases matter 

Large public-health datasets are valuable, but aggregation can obscure important differences between individual cases. 

Some of the notifications cited in the allegations by Public Eye, for example, refer to products that Syngenta stopped selling in Brazil more than 5 years ago.  

Understanding those circumstances does not diminish the tragedy. It is essential if our shared objective is to understand what happened and prevent similar incidents in future. 

Real people deserve rigorous evidence 

We have engaged with Public Eye and provided detailed responses because pesticide poisoning is an important public-health issue and legitimate scrutiny should be taken seriously. 

But scrutiny also requires the underlying evidence to be handled with care. 

Behind every record is a person. They deserve compassion and serious efforts to prevent harm. They also deserve an accurate account of what the evidence actually shows. 

Frequently Asked Questions:

  • How does Syngenta ensure the safety of its products and operations?

    At Syngenta, safety is at the heart of everything we do. From the earliest stages of research and development through manufacturing, distribution, and use in the field, we apply rigorous standards designed to protect people, communities, and the environment.  

    • Designing Products for Safety and Responsible Performance 
      Syngenta’s “safer-by-design” approach in R&D means that we embed safety and sustainability into our products - right from the earliest stages of our scientific discovery. We bring together our deep expertise in plant biology, toxicology, ecotoxicology and chemistry with leading-edge computational modelling, predictive science and machine learning - to design our technologies so that they meet multiple objectives simultaneously: effectiveness, crop safety, human safety, environmental stewardship and sustainability.  
    • Extensive Scientific Testing and Compliance with Stringent Global Regulations 
      Crop protection products are among the most highly regulated products in the world. Every crop protection product undergoes years of development in which safety relevant scientific data are generated followed by an evaluation before it can be approved for use. Every product is thoroughly assessed for potential impacts on human health, operators, consumers, and the environment. Regulatory authorities around the world review extensive scientific data before granting initial approvals, and reapprovals, for use.   
      As a leader in the industry, Syngenta welcomes robust regulation as an essential part of ensuring high standards across the industry.  
    • Safety of manufacturing operations 
      At Syngenta, safety is built into every stage of our manufacturing operations - to protect employees, contractors, neighboring communities, and the environment while producing the technologies farmers depend on. Our approach combines strong standards, rigorous risk management, employee training, operational discipline and continuous learning.  
      Syngenta implements structured risk assessment processes to identify hazards, understand potential consequences, and establish safeguards. Process safety management protocols integrate health, safety, engineering, technical and manufacturing disciplines to help prevent major incidents. Our manufacturing sites employ a wide range of established operational controls, including equipment inspections and maintenance programs, while our operational teams continuously monitor performance, and implement preventive actions to strengthen safety. Furthermore, we invest significantly in training and competency programs that help our employees and contractors understand risk, follow procedures and perform their roles safely, while implementing ongoing monitoring, audits, reporting and learning processes.  
    • Promoting Responsible Use Through Stewardship and Training 
      Safety depends not only on product design but also on how products are used. Syngenta supports farmer training, stewardship programs, digital tools, and guidance to help growers apply products safely and responsibly. Clear label instructions, appropriate handling practices, and the use of personal protective equipment where required are key components of safe use.  
    • Continuous Improvement and Accountability 
      Safety is an ongoing commitment. Syngenta continually reviews its portfolio, evaluates new scientific evidence, and works to improve products and practices. The company aligns its safety approaches with internationally recognized standards and guidelines from organizations such as the FAO, WHO, OECD, and regulatory authorities around the world. 
       
  • Why does Syngenta export pesticides from Europe to developing countries?

    Agricultural needs differ significantly worldwide – reflecting widely varying pest pressure, climate, and crop systems. Syngenta’s role is to provide farmers around the world access to high-quality agricultural solutions they need, to effectively address local agricultural challenges, in full compliance with local regulations.  

    It is important to know that the pesticides industry is one of the most highly regulated industries in the world, and the use of agrochemical products in each country is determined by national governments, based on scientific assessments by their own regulatory authorities who also weigh the risks and benefits in their own country. Any export of hazardous products – for example from Europe - is undertaken only with regulatory oversight of the importing country and must conform to global treaties governing the export of chemicals, namely the Prior Informed Consent (PIC) procedure under the Rotterdam Convention. Furthermore, in developing countries which may have less mature regulatory expertise, Syngenta only sells products where the active ingredient(s) contained in the formulated product have already been approved by an OECD country.

    It is also important to understand that producing active ingredients for crop protection is a highly complex process. To ensure that our compounds meet the stringent production standards and have the highest quality, Syngenta produces in only a few places around the world, from where we export to more than 90 countries. Syngenta’s high-tech production operations - such as those in Europe - are global centers of excellence with proven track records of safe and responsible operations. For this reason, Syngenta’s European manufacturing facilities may manufacture products no longer needed domestically but are deemed essential by farmers and regulators in the importing country.  

    When exporting products from Europe, Syngenta respects the sovereignty and direction of the importing country, meets all the international regulatory requirements - including the above-mentioned PIC procedure of the Rotterdam Convention - and provides stewardship and detailed information in country to promote the safe application by end users. 

  • Does Syngenta train farmers in the proper use of its products?

    Of course. In fact, Syngenta Group trained 16.9 million people in 2025 around the world on safe and responsible use of Syngenta products. Training covers topics such as safe handling and application, use of personal protective equipment, environmental protection measures, and best agronomic practices. In Brazil alone, we trained close to 95,000 people in 2025, reflecting our commitment to supporting farmers through practical, on-the-ground education and stewardship initiatives.

  • How are pesticides regulated in Brazil?

    In Brazil, products may be registered following a rigorous assessment by the Brazilian Health Regulatory Agency (Anvisa), the Brazilian Institute of Environment and Renewable Natural Resources (Ibama), and the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Food Supply (MAPA), which evaluate aspects related to human health, environmental safety and agronomic efficacy.

  • What is Syngenta’s view of a recent study by Pesticide Action Network that claimed “almost half of the world’s farmers are poisoned by pesticides every year”?

    The study is a reiteration of a 2020 version, which was retracted due to methodological flaws. The 2026 publication retains the same authors and reaches similar conclusions to the earlier version. Please see here the full letter to the editors that laid out the reasoning for the retraction of the earlier study.

    We note that the recent study fails to fix the retracted 2020 methodology: The 2026 update relies on essentially the same unvalidated methods that caused the original 2020 paper to be retracted, despite adding limited sensitivity checks. The authors chose to use the 2026 publication to justify the rationale for their approach to the data interpretation and apply it, largely unchanged, to an updated data set.

    Further, the study uses inconsistent and overly broad definitions of poisoning: The study artificially inflates numbers by counting past lifetime events, unverified and non-specific symptoms, and even cases with no symptoms at all as annual poisonings.

    In addition, the study employs massive extrapolation from small, unrepresentative samples: Global and regional estimates are calculated by scaling up very small, non-random, localized groups of people to entire national and continental populations.

    As a leader in agricultural innovation, Syngenta believes it is important to have constructive and informed dialogue on the role of crop protection and the use of pesticides in sustainable food production.